“Coachability is not just teachability. It’s not just a willingness to learn. It’s a willingness to unlearn and change. Coachability is a moral capacity that allows a person to accept feedback, acknowledge faults, limitations, and deficiencies, and to act on that new information.” (Timothy Clark)
As instructional coaches and school leaders, we can play a big role in shaping culture of coachability. We do it through the way we listen, the questions we ask, and the tone we set when offering feedback.
Find Timothy Clark’s article, “Are You Coachable?” here.
Subscribe to the Steve Barkley Ponders Out Loud podcast on iTunes or visit BarkleyPD.com to find new episodes!
Podcast Transcript:
[00:00:00.290] – Steve [Intro]
Welcome to the Steve Barkley Ponders Out Loud podcast. As instructional coaches and school leaders, you are tasked with guiding continuous teacher growth to create student success. This podcast looks to support you with strategies from experienced guests, as well as my own insights that I’ve gathered over the years. I’m thrilled to have you with us. Thanks for tuning in.
[00:00:29.420] – Steve
Building Coachability for myself and others. Consider this quote from Timothy Clarke: “Coachability is not just teachability. It’s not just a willingness to learn. It’s a willingness to unlearn and change. Coachability is a moral capacity that allows a person to accept feedback, acknowledge faults, limitations, and deficiencies, and to act upon that new information.” Let me say that strong part again. “A willingness to learn and unlearn and change.” That phrase jumped out at me because it captures the deeper challenge of growth. It’s not just about gaining new strategies or skills. It’s about being willing to let go of practices, beliefs, or habits that may no longer serve us or our students. In an earlier podcast, I explored the idea of promoting coachability, what coaches and leaders can do to help others open up to feedback and reflection.
[00:01:36.400] – Steve
In this episode, I want to take that idea further. I want to focus on what it takes to build coachability, not just in others, but also in ourselves. Coachability isn’t just a characteristic someone either has or doesn’t have. It’s something that can be nurtured. It’s a mindset we can develop and a culture we can shape. For starters, coachability starts with me. Early in my presenting and consulting career, I learned the joy, and sometimes the pain, of reading evaluations of my work several times a week. When I did read through a stack of 100 participants’ comments, there were generally 75% that were excellent and maybe 20% good and 5% that were terrible. As I began to read those, I would wonder what problem the 5% of the people had that prevented them from getting the value out of the work that I had done. Now, as my confidence grew in my own abilities, I began to learn that those negative evaluations frequently contain some seed of opportunity for my improvement. The negative comments might explain what caused some of the participants who rated the session as good instead of excellent, more than I could gain from reading the comments from those people who had rated it as good.
[00:03:09.130] – Steve
High coachability leads us to an opportunity for continuous growth. As a coach or school leader, one of the most powerful messages I can send is, I am coachable. That means I’m open to feedback, I invite it, I reflect on it, and I act on it. I’ve worked with leaders who ask their teachers for feedback after a presentation the leader made to parents at an open house. I’ve seen coaches who record themselves during a conference and then ask a colleague to debrief the recording with them. These actions model coachability in a very real and visible way. When I make it clear that I’m still learning, I open the door for others to do the same. I also try to pause when I feel that natural resistance bubble up. You know that voice inside you that says, “That’s not what I said,” or, “I’ve been doing it this way for years.” That’s often a signal that I might be bumping up against something I need to learn or probably unlearn. In highly effective schools, coachability isn’t just an individual trait. It’s a shared expectation. Leaders seek feedback and talk openly about their own growth. Teachers welcome coaching, not as a sign of weakness, but as part of their professional identity.
[00:04:43.060] – Steve
Teams use peer feedback and reflection as part of their practice every day. There is a culture of psychological safety where people feel respected, heard, and safe to take risks. Psychological safety is the belief that it’s safe to take interpersonal risks, like asking for help, admitting a mistake, or sharing an idea that might not be perfect. It’s what allows someone to be open, vulnerable, and coachable. When psychological safety is present, teachers are more likely to say, “Can you watch my class and give me some feedback on something I’m trying?” A team member might share, “I’m struggling with student engagement. I’d love your thoughts.” A leader can admit, that initiative didn’t go the way I hoped. What can we learn from it? But when psychological safety is missing, even the most well-intentional coaching can feel like an evaluation or a judgment. We build psychological safety through active listening. People feel safer when they know they’re being heard, not managed. Consistency and follow-through are critical. When our words and our actions match, trust grows. Empathy – when someone feels understood and supported, they’re more likely to open up. Psychological safety actually raises the bar. When people feel safe, they’re more willing to take on meaningful, challenging growth.
[00:06:36.390] – Steve
As instructional coaches and school leaders, we can play a big role in shaping this culture. We do it through the way we listen, the questions we ask, and the tone that we set when offering feedback. We also build coachability when we acknowledge effort and vulnerability. When someone tries something new, even if it doesn’t work, that’s a win. That’s growth. Looking to build coachability in others, I remind myself I can’t force it. I can foster it. That means paying attention to where someone is in their learning journey. Some teachers are wide open and ready for the next challenge. Others may be hesitant, maybe even burned by past experiences. I need to meet them where they are, not where I want them to be. Asking questions that invite reflection without pressure gives people room to process and to grow their own coachability over time. Questions like, “What’s something you’re trying to figure out right now?” Or, “What role might I play in exploring possibilities or observing and providing feedback?” In my mind, timing matters. Sometimes a conversation that doesn’t land today might open the door next week or next month. I work to stay curious, patient, and present.
[00:08:17.170] – Steve
Here’s a story about an instructional coach named Rachel, whose questions helped to build psychological safety and coachability. Rachel was a new instructional coach at a school where coaching hadn’t been well-established. Teachers were unsure what to expect, and many were a bit guarded. Rather than waiting for teachers to come to her, Rachel made a point to spend time in classrooms, not just observing, but learning. She’d always follow up with a short one-on-one conversation, and instead of giving feedback, she’d ask questions like, “What are your students working that excites or challenges you?” “If there was one thing you wish you had more time to explore with your students, what would that be?” “What have you learned about your students in these first few days of school?” These weren’t evaluation-driven questions. They were relationship-building questions. They were an invitation for the teacher to share, reflect, and lead the direction reflection of the conversation. One teacher, Megan, told Rachel about a group of students who were strong in class discussion but struggled to put their ideas in writing. Rachel didn’t jump in with strategies. Instead, she said, “That’s intriguing. What have you been considering? What have you been thinking might be getting in their way?”
[00:09:56.550] – Steve
That moment changed things because Rachel had shown respect for Megan’s thinking and curiosity about her students, not just her instruction. Megan opened up. She said, “I’d love to brainstorm some ways to bridge that gap. Could we talk about it next week?” That “yes” wasn’t just an invitation to collaborate. It was a sign of coachability. It happened not because Rachel had all the answers, but because she created safety through questions that communicated, I see you. I value your insights. I’m here to learn with you. In the weeks that followed, Rachel used that same approach with other teachers. By being generally curious Curious, listening deeply and affirming what was working, she built trust faster and helped coachability emerge earlier than it might have otherwise. I’m currently working with a group of teachers who are exploring building peer coaching into their school culture. Here are a few questions that we’re discussing in order to decide some next steps. Maybe these questions fit into an upcoming staff meeting of yours. “How would you describe the general mindset of coachability at our school?” “What impacts your personal degree of openness to feedback?” “When are you more coachable or less coachable?”
[00:11:33.410] – Steve
“What conditions would build and support coachability among our staff?” Let me leave you with these two questions. What’s something you’ve recently unlearned or are working to unlearn. And the biggie, who’s coaching you? Jim Knight put it this way, “When we’re open to feedback, we are open to growth. The more coachable the more we are, the more likely we are to become the teacher or coach we aspire to be. As we ask others to be open, reflective, and growth-focused, we need to hold that mirror up to ourselves because our own coachability is the foundation for the work we do.” Coachability is contagious. Let’s build it, model it, and support it together. Thanks for tuning in.
[00:12:42.500] – Steve [Outro]
Thanks for listening, folks. I’d love to hear what your’re pondering. You can find me on Twitter or LinkedIn at Steve Barkley, or send me your questions and find my videos and blogs at barkleypd.com.









