In Coaching, Haste Could Make Waste — or Worse - Steve Barkley

In Coaching, Haste Could Make Waste — or Worse

How often has this happened to you? You’re listening to a teacher describe her frustration with a group of students. Halfway through, you recognize the situation. You’ve seen it before. You solved it when you were teaching. You know what will help. Even if you don’t interrupt, you’re no longer fully listening — you’re thinking about what you will say. Without realizing it, you’ve stopped being curious.

Haste in coaching rarely looks rude. It often looks helpful.

Whether you’re supporting a teacher, facilitating a professional learning team, or working with a school leader, listening is foundational. When we think we already understand, we predict solutions early and easily slip into haste. We nod instead of reflect. We respond instead of inquire. We react instead of understand.

One listening danger is responding too quickly. That’s haste. When people sense that the listener rushed to a conclusion, they often feel unimportant — even if the response is positive. Coaches can easily fall into the haste trap because they recognize patterns quickly and solutions form early. With a solution in mind, coaches can miss crucial signals, undermine trust, and interpret teachers’ questions as pushback.

Coaches work too hard to build a coaching culture to have it eroded by haste.

Coaches collaborating with a PLC can fall into haste when they are asked the triggering question, “What do you suggest we do?” The question sounds like an invitation, but it can be a trap. While you know you should lead with questions to gather their observations and thinking, the opportunity to be helpful calls out to you. If you respond too quickly, it can feel disempowering.

A coach’s haste might sound like this:

“What if you tried _______?”

“We don’t have time to worry about that now.”

“I think what’s really going on here is _________.”

“Let’s talk about what to do.”

Even great suggestions offered too soon can short-circuit the deeper exploration that leads to teacher growth and ownership. When Christine Miles, author of, “What’s It Costing You to Not Listen?“, joined me on a podcast, she pointed out that most of us have little training in listening.

“I hear leaders doing listening tours and things like that, but they’re really talking more than they’re actually listening. It’s a problem that most people don’t know exists because we’ve been told to listen and very rarely taught how. So I think listening is very misunderstood.”

Miles suggests that the moment we think, “I’ve seen this before,” we stop being curious. Yet every classroom situation has nuances — like a snowflake. Chances are we are missing something critical. Miles calls this a closeness bias: the more we know something, the less curious we become.

Coaches need to get the full picture and ensure the coachee knows they are understood. Our first job is to understand the message and the intent of the speaker — and respond only after that job is done.

When a coach moves too quickly to a solution, the teacher doesn’t experience support — they experience evaluation. In that moment, teacher reflection stops. The lesson may improve, but the teacher’s decision-making does not. Even when the coach is kind and the idea is promising, the teacher may conclude, “The coach already knows what I should do.” That interpretation interferes with the coaching relationship and culture you want to build.

Consider recording an upcoming coaching conference and checking your listening. Are there any spots where haste crept in?

Coaching often doesn’t break down because the coach said the wrong thing. It breaks down because the coach said the right thing too soon.

Share Button
image_pdfDownloadimage_printPrint

Leave a Reply

Blog: Steve Barkley Ponders Out Loud

Share Button
image_pdfDownloadimage_printPrint

Listen to Steve Barkley’s Latest Podcast

Share Button
image_pdfDownloadimage_printPrint

The Academy for Educators

Become an expert in instructional coaching, blended and online learning strategies, engaging 21st Century learners, and more with online PD from PLS 3rd Learning.
Learn more

Share Button
image_pdfDownloadimage_printPrint