In many schools today, teacher dissatisfaction is easy to find and just as easy to misunderstand. When frustration surfaces, leaders sometimes respond by encouraging teachers to “stay positive.” Such statements feel like imposed positivity and sounds more like dismissal than support. It often communicates a lack of understanding and empathy.
Research has consistently shown that teacher dissatisfaction is more than a passing emotion. Drawing on the work of Christina Maslach and others, we know that when teachers lose a sense of accomplishment and control, burnout increases, engagement drops, and the impact reaches students as well as staff. Studies on teacher motivation and retention further highlight that dissatisfaction is closely tied to teachers’ decisions to disengage—or even leave the profession.
Christina Maslach developed the Maslach Burnout Inventory (MBI), which defines burnout as a three-dimensional syndrome:
- Emotional exhaustion, which reflects intense fatigue and loss of energy in the face of the demands of work.
- Depersonalization or cynicism, which manifests itself in a distant, even negative, attitude towards colleagues, customers or patients.
- Reduced personal accomplishment, when the person feels that their work is no longer valuable and they can no longer feel competent.
I reflected on issues related to teacher dissatisfaction and the role of coaching while reading a SmartBrief post titled, The happiness factor: How positivity makes a leader more effective. The author, LaRae Quy, explores the role of happiness in effective leadership. She reminds us that happiness isn’t simply the mood we choose. It grows from how people interpret challenges, where they experience agency, and whether they notice the impact of their efforts. Those elements are deeply connected to teachers’ professional satisfaction and should be components of effective coaching.
Teacher dissatisfaction isn’t something to fix or avoid—it’s something to listen to. When explored thoughtfully, it often becomes the starting point for renewed purpose, increased agency, and stronger professional satisfaction.
Here are three suggestions LaRae Quy proposes for leaders that translate especially well into instructional coaching practice:
Distinguish between happiness and positive thinking:
“The key distinction between happiness and positive thinking is that happiness is an emotion that reflects how we feel right now, whereas positive thinking is a mindset that continually shapes our responses and our view of our circumstances, both negative and positive, as we move forward.” (LaRae Quy)
Positive thinking is not simply encouraging someone to “look on the bright side.” That response can unintentionally communicate that frustration should be minimized rather than explored. When teachers are facing real challenges with students, curriculum demands, time pressures, or uncertainty about impact, simply encouraging positivity can feel like their experience is being discounted. Teachers experience professional satisfaction when they see evidence that what they do matters—even when the work remains complex and demanding. This is where coaching plays a powerful role. Rather than redirecting teachers toward optimism, coaches create space for teachers to examine what is happening and what is possible.
Questions like this can help shift the conversation from imposed positivity to professional agency:
Talk about a recent discovery you made that had a positive impact for you.
Where are you most comfortable with the progress you are making?
What initial change in the students (or a particular student) would indicate progress?
Teachers are not looking for someone to make them feel better 🙂. They are looking for someone who will help them think better about what they can do next. When that shift occurs, satisfaction begins to grow—not because challenges disappear, but because teachers reconnect with their capacity to influence learning.
Embrace what you can control:
Much of teachers’ frustration comes from working in conditions they cannot immediately change—curriculum mandates, testing requirements, scheduling limitations, or student needs that feel overwhelming. When attention stays centered on those factors, a sense of helplessness can grow. Over time, that loss of control feeds the emotional exhaustion and reduced accomplishment that Christina Maslach identified as central elements of burnout.
Coaching can offer an important interruption to that cycle by assisting teachers in identifying where their influence still exists. Instead of attempting to solve everything at once, coaching conversations can help teachers explore questions such as:
Where do you have the greatest opportunity to try something different right now?
Which student responses are giving you information you can build on?
What instructional move feels worth experimenting with next?
These questions do not ignore the real challenges teachers face. They help teachers reclaim their professional agency within those challenges. I have often found that when teachers shift from describing what they cannot change to identifying what they can influence, their energy changes as well. Even small instructional decisions—adjusting questioning strategies, trying a new feedback routine, or collaborating with a colleague—can restore a sense of progress.
Choose to be grateful:
Gratitude in a professional setting is about recognizing evidence that our work is making a difference. Teachers often move quickly from one lesson to the next, one student need to another, one responsibility to the next deadline. In that pace, moments of impact can pass unnoticed. Over time, when teachers stop seeing evidence of their influence, satisfaction declines—even when important learning is happening.
Coaching questions can provide reflection time for teachers to notice and value results:
When did you notice students thinking differently?
What surprised you in a positive way during the lesson?
Where did a student respond differently than before?
What is a change you have made that is encouraging? Why?
These kinds of coaching questions help teachers pause long enough to recognize progress. Those moments are not small. They are the signals teachers use to judge whether their work matters. When teachers reconnect with evidence of their influence on learners, they are more likely to persist, experiment, and collaborate with colleagues. Over time, those small recognitions accumulate into something larger—a renewed sense of professional satisfaction grounded not in circumstances being easier, but in teachers seeing more clearly the difference they are making every day.
Teacher dissatisfaction is not a signal that something is wrong with teachers. More often, it is a signal that something important to teachers needs attention—their sense of impact, agency, and connection to purpose. Collaboration with colleagues often expands those areas of influence even further, which is one reason coaching cultures increase professional satisfaction across a school.
Happiness may come and go across a school year. Professional satisfaction grows differently. It develops when teachers see students responding, when they recognize progress, and when they experience themselves continuing to learn.
Coaching helps make those experiences visible—and when teachers see the difference they are making, professional satisfaction grows.









