Balancing Complexity and Simplicity: The Coaching Challenge - Steve Barkley

Balancing Complexity and Simplicity: The Coaching Challenge

Throughout my years working as a staff developer and coach to teachers and administrators, I have emphasized the importance of supporting educators by simplifying complex concepts while still respecting their intricacy. For an instructional strategy or facilitative technique to be learned and practiced, it must be broken down into a sequence of simple steps. Without this simplification, the learner cannot effectively begin the process. However, it is equally important to acknowledge the complexity of teaching or leadership practices, as failing to do so may cause learners to abandon the process when they encounter challenges.

This dilemma is well illustrated in the Joyce/Showers research on implementing new teaching practices.

The research indicates that studying a theory, hearing how it is done, observing it being modeled, and practicing in a controlled setting provide a “simple” starting point. In this context, participants can successfully execute the strategy during the workshop. However, for the strategy to be effectively implemented in the classroom and impact student learning (which is more complex) or implementing with staff to drive change, ongoing coaching support is necessary.

Effective instructional strategies are essential for fostering a productive learning process. However, the way these strategies are presented to teachers can significantly impact their implementation and success. To optimize both understanding and application, it’s crucial that teaching strategies are presented as both complex and simple. The complex presentation provides a thorough understanding of the strategy’s theoretical foundations and nuances, while the simple presentation offers a clear, step-by-step guide for initial implementation. This dual approach empowers teachers to grasp the full scope of a strategy and gradually master its application in their classrooms.

This statement by Joyce and Showers illustrates the need for combining simple practice execution with the complexity of the classroom.

“Athletes do not believe mastery will be achieved quickly or easily. As teachers, we have often behaved as though teaching skills were so easily acquired that a presentation, workshop, or demonstration could ensure classroom performance. To the extent, we have communicated this message to teachers we have probably misled them.”

As an example, consider teachers building their formative assessment practices through the simple and complex lens.

Research and Value:

Formative assessment involves using various methods to monitor student learning and provide ongoing information that can be used by instructors to make teaching decisions and by students to focus their next learning behaviors. Research highlights the value of formative assessment in increasing student engagement, motivation, and achievement. It allows teachers to identify learning gaps, adapt instruction to meet students’ needs, and enhance the learning experience.

Complexity in Classrooms:

The complexity of formative assessment lies in its multifaceted nature. It encompasses a range of techniques, including questioning, discussions, peer assessment, self-assessment, and the teacher’s and students’ use of information gained. Implementing formative assessment effectively requires teachers to skillfully integrate these techniques into their instructional practices, interpret student responses, and adjust their teaching accordingly. This complexity can be daunting, especially for new teachers.

Simplify initial classroom application

Start Small: Begin with one or two formative assessment techniques. (questioning practices, exit tickets, self-check activities) Gradually expand repertoire as you become more comfortable.

Communicate with Students: Explain the purpose of the formative assessment practices you are implementing to your students. Emphasize that it is a tool for learning, not evaluation.

Monitoring and Feedback: Consider debriefing the information gained from the assessment with your students. How are you as a teacher using the knowledge to guide instruction. How can the students use the information?

Reflection and Adjustment: Reflect on the effectiveness of the formative assessment techniques you are using. How well did they provide insights into student learning for you and your students. This is a great spot to reflect with a coach. The coach observing students as you employ the strategy or share the results can add insights for your decision- making.

By presenting teaching and leading strategies as both complex and simple, educators can build their confidence and expertise. This balanced approach ensures that they not only understand the underlying principles but also have practical steps to follow, leading to more effective and meaningful implementation. Ultimately, the journey of mastering key strategies is ongoing, requiring continuous reflection, adaptation, and support. Embracing this duality allows educators to grow professionally while enhancing the learning experiences of their students, fostering a culture of continuous improvement and excellence in education.


Share Button
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Blog: Steve Barkley Ponders Out Loud

Share Button
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Listen to Steve Barkley’s Latest Podcast

Share Button
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The Academy for Educators

Become an expert in instructional coaching, blended and online learning strategies, engaging 21st Century learners, and more with online PD from PLS 3rd Learning.
Learn more

Share Button
Print Friendly, PDF & Email